Guilty by Association: Addressing Sustainability in Architecture Education

Tyana Santini

Despite the growing interest in sustainability, negative associations of this term with naïve discourses, green-washing, or low-quality design are still common within some areas in the discipline of architecture. Through a literature review and an examination of the programs of the top ten architecture schools, this article explores the causes and implications of this slight but persistent discredit of sustainability in the field of architecture. The article discusses how some of the perceived downsides of sustainability are reflected on the university curricula, as the fragmented understanding of environmental problems or the overly technical approach to their solution within technology and design. The discussion also addresses the improvements brought by recent multidisciplinary explorations of environmental issues made within the architectural humanities, that provide students a comprehensive historical, social, and cultural understanding of the issue.

Keywords

Sustainability; architecture education; green-washing; sustainable architecture; environmental humanities

References

Altomonte S. (2009). Environmental Education for Sustainable Architecture. Review of European Studies, 1(2), 12-21.

American Institute of Architects (AIA) (2006). Ecology and Design. Ecological Literacy in Architectural Education. 2006 Report and Proposal (pp. 21-40). The AIA Committee on the Environment.

Axel N., Colomina B., Hirsch N., Vidokle A., Wigley M. (Eds.) (2018) Superhumanity: Design of the Self. Minnesota: U. of Minnesota Press.

Baird G. (2011). Sustainability Scrutinized. Architectural Record, 199(8), 27.

Batty M., Marshall S.W. (2012), The Origins of Complexity Theory in Cities and Planning. In: Portugali J., Meyer H., Stolk E. (Eds.) Complexity Theories of Cities Have Come of Age. (pp. 24-47). Berlin: Springer Verlag.

Blaviesciunaite A., Cole R. J. (2011). The Cultural Values Embedded in Building Environmental Assessment Methods: A Comparison of LEED and CASBEE. Proceedings of the International Sustainable Building Conference. Helsinki, Finland, 18–21 October 2011.

Brillembourg A., Klumpner H. (2017). Radical Jozi: Housing the Inner City. ETH Zurich. Course Catalog. Retrived from: http:// www.vvz.ethz.ch/Vorlesungsverzeichnis/lerneinheit.view?lerneinheitId=113973&semkez=2017S&ansicht=KATALOGDATEN〈=en.

Broersma S. (2016). Zero-Energy Design. TU Delft Course Browser. Retrieved from: http://www.studiegids.tudelft.nl/a101_displayCourse.do?course_id=41031.

Buchanan P. (2012). The Big Rethink: Rethinking Architectural Education. The Architectural Review. Retrieved 05 22, 2017, from The Arch. Review: http://www.architectural-review.com/academia/the-big-rethink-part-9-rethinking-architectural-education/863 6035.article

Carmeliet J., Koebel M., von Trzebiatowski O. F., Zimmermann Schütz T. A. (2016). Building Materials I. ETH Zurich Vorlesungsverzeichnis. Retrieved from: http://www.vvz.ethz.ch/Vorlesungsverzeichnis/lerneinheit.view?lerneinheitId=109394&semkez=2016W&ansicht=KATALOGDATEN〈=en

Carr D. (2004) Moral Values and the Arts in Environmental Education: Towards an Ethics of Aesthetic Appreciation. Journal of Philosophy of Education, 38(2), 221-239.

Castillo G. (2016). ARCH 179, 003 [CASTILLO] "Design Radicals: The Bay Area Counterculture Legacy". Retrieved 2017, from Berkeley Architecture/ 2017 Courses: https://ced.berkeley.edu/academics/architecture/courses/spring-2017-courses/

Cole R. J., Valdebenito M. J. (2013). The importation of building environmental certification systems: international usages of BREEAM and LEED. Building Research and Information, 41(6), 662-676.

College of Environmental Design, University of California Berkeley. (2016). Sustainable Environmental Design Major Handbook 2016-2017. University of California Berkeley.

Crawford M., Stewart A. (2017). Seminars/Art of writing. Retrieved from: http://artofwriting.berkeley.edu/buildings-cities/

Cronon W. (1995). Uncommon Ground: Rethinking the Human Place in Nature. New York: Norton & Co.

Czajkowski J. D. (2016) Perceptions of Sustainability. Interview by T. Santini, unpublished. December.

Dirlich S. (2012). The building stock and traditional building principles: sustainability assessment for historic buildings. Proceedings of the 1st International Conference on Building Sustainability Assessment, 31-38.

Eisenman P. (2009). Vladimir Belogolovsky interviews architect and educator Peter Eisenman. MasComtext. Retrieved from: http://www.mascontext.com/issues/10-conflict-summer-11/changes-are-coming/

Fuller R. (2010). Beyond Cliché – Reclaiming the Concept of Sustainability. Australian Journal of Environmental Education, 26, 7-18.

Gale F., Davison A., Wood G., Williams, S., Towle N. (2015). Four Impediments to Embedding Education for Sustainability in Higher Education. Australian Journal of Environmental Education, 31(2), 248-263.

Ghosn R. (2016). Landscapes of Energy. MIT Course Catalog 2016-2017. Retrieved from: http://catalog.mit.edu/archive/2016-2017/schools/architecture-planning/architecture/#subjectstext

Graham W. (2016). Are we greening our cities, or just greenwashing them? Los Angeles Times. Retrieved from: http://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-graham-folly-of-green-buildings-20160306-story.html

Green S. (2018). Sustainable Construction: Contested Knowledge and the Decline of Professionalism. In T. Dixon, & J. G. Connaughton, Sustainable Futures in the Built Environment to 2050 (172-193). Oxford: Wiley.

Gucyeter B. (2016). The Place of Sustainability in Architectural Education: Discussion and Suggestions. Athens Journal of Arch., 237-255.

Guy S., Moore S. A. (2007). Sustainable Architecture and the Pluralist Imagination. Journal of Architectural Education (1984-), 60(4), 15-23.

Hassanpour B.; Alpar Atun R.; Ghaderi S. (2017) From Words to Action: Incorporation of Sustainability in Architectural Education. Sustainability, 9, 1790.

Hein C. (2009). Global Landscapes of Oil. New Geographies 02: Landscapes of Energy, 2, 33-42.

Hein C. (2016). Building Green: Past, Present, Future. TU Delft Study Guide. Retrieved from: http://www.studiegids.tudelft.nl/a101_displayCourse.do?course_id=41019

Hein C. (2017). Architecture and Urbanism Beyond Oil. TU Delft Study Guide. Retrieved from: http://www.studiegids.tudelft.nl/a101_displayCourse.do?course_id=38486

Higgins B., Thomas I. (2016). Education for Sustainability in Universities: Challenges and Opportunities for Change. Australian Journal of Environmental Education, 32(1), 91-108.

Hosey L. (2012). The Shape of Green. Washington: Island Press.

Hurley K. A. (2009). Surprising Shades of Green. The Journal of the American Institute of Architects, 98(10), 8. Retrieved from: http://www.architectmagazine.com/technology/do-architects-believe-in-global-warming-readers-weigh-in_o

Ismail M. A., Keumala N., Dabdoob R. M. (2017). Review on integrating sustainability knowledge into architectural education: Practice in the UK and the USA. Journal of Cleaner Production.140, 1542-1552.

Iulo L. D., Gorby C., Poerschke, U., Kalisperis L. N., Woollen M. (2013). Environmentally conscious design. Educating future architects. International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education, 14(4), 434-448.

Jacobsen M. H., Tester K. (2016) Utopia: Social Theory and the Future. New York: Routledge.

Jaimes P. (2016). Perceptions of Sustainability. Interview by T. Santini, unpublished. December 2016.

Jarzombek M. (1999). Molecules, Money and Design: The Question of Sustainability's Role in Architectural Academe. Thresholds (18), 32-38.

Jarzombek M. (2016). 4.S68 Special Subject: Study in Modern Architecture — SOCIAL SPACE(S). Retrieved from: MIT Archietcture/History, Theory+Criticism/Subjects: http://architecture.mit.edu/subject/fall-2016-4s68.

Jarzombek, M. (2009). Mark Jarzombek. Politics of Sustainability. [Video File] Retrieved from: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LItsK_aAVEc&t=80s

Jurado M. (2016). Greenwashing Architecture? The Myths of Sustainable Buildings. Clarin. Retrieved from: https://www.worldcrunch.com/green-or-gone-1/greenwashing-architecture-the-myths-of-sustainable-buildings.

Kahn A. Z., Vandevyvere H., Allacker K. (2013). Design for the Ecological Age: Rethinking the Role of Sustainability in Architectural Education. Journal of Architectural Education, 67(2), 175-185.

Koolhaas R. (2009). Office for Metropolitan Architecture (OMA) official site. Retrieved from Lectures/Sustainability: Advancement vs. Apocalypse: http://oma.eu/lectures/sustainability-advancement-vs-apocalypse.

Koolhaas R. (2014). My thoughts on the smart city. European Commission. Digital Minds for a New Europe. Retrieved from: http://ec.europa.eu/archives/commission_2010-2014/kroes/en/content/my-thoughts-smart-city-rem-koolhaas.html.

Koolhaas R. (2017). Rotterdam Study Abroad Studio Option: Countryside. GSD Courses. Retrieved from: http://www.gsd.harvard.edu/course/rotterdam-study-abroad-studio-option-countryside-fall-2017/.

Kozak D. (2014). Sustentabilidad en Arquitectura Urbana. Revista Notas. 25, 21.

Kozak D. (2016). erceptions of Sustainability. Interview by T. Santini, unpublished. December 2016.

Latour B. (2004). Politics of nature: how to bring the sciences into democracy. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Lee S. (2016). Aesthetics of Sustainable Architecture. TU Delft/Courses/Architecture. Retrieved from: http://www.studiegids.tudelft.nl/a101_displayCourse.do?course_id=41020.

Malkawi A., Gill G. (2017). Energy Residential High-Rise. Harvard GSD Courses. Retrieved from: http://www.gsd.harvard.edu/course/zero-energy-residential-high-rise-spring-2017/.

Manchester School of Architecture (2017). BA (Hons) Architecture. Retrieved from: http://www.msa.ac.uk/study/ba/.

Marcuse P. (1998) Sustainability is not enough. Environment and Urbanization, 10 (2), 103-111.

Marsh R., Pilkington P., Rice L. (2020). A guide to architecture for the public health workforce, Public Health, 178, 120-123.

Moe K. (2007) Compelling yet Unreliable Theories of Sustainability. Journal of Architectural Education (JAE), 60 (4), 24-30.

Morton T. (2007) Ecology without Nature. Rethinking Environmental Aesthetics. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Neimanis A., Åsber C., Hedrén J. (2015). Four Problems, Four directions of Environmental Humanities. Ethics & The Environment, 20(1), 67-97.

Newsham G. R., Mancini, S., Birt, B. J. (2009). Do LEED-certified buildings save energy? Yes, but…. Energy & Buildings, 41, 897-905.

NUS. (2016). Topics In Urban Studies - Shaping Liveable Places. NUS School of Design and Environment-Regitrar´s office. Retrieved from: https://inetapps.nus.edu.sg/bulletin/msearch_view_full.aspx?modeCode=AR5952N.

NUS. (2017). Renewable Resources and Architecture. National University of Singapores/Sraech Modules. Retrieved from: https://inetapps.nus.edu.sg/bulletin/msearch_view_full.aspx?modeCode=AR5322.

Ochsendorf J. (2016). Design for Sustainability. MIT Open Courseware. Retrieved from: http://catalog.mit.edu/archive/2016-2017/schools/architecture-planning/architecture/#subjectstext.

Ochsendorf J., & Mueller, C. (2016). Building Structural Systems I. MIT Architecture-Building Technology- Subjects. Retrieved from: http://architecture.mit.edu/disciplines/building-technology/subjects?semesterxx=578 Retrieved 2017.

OMA (2018) Office Work. Retrieved from: http://oma.eu/projects.

Ortiz O., Castells F., Sonnemann G. (2009). Sustainability in the construction industry: A review of recent developments based on LCA. Construction and Building Materials. 23(1). 28-39.

Pareja M. E., Støa E. (2004) Dimensions of housing and urban sustainability. Journal of Housing and the Built Environment, 19(1), 1-5.

Peterson R., Wood, P. W. (2015) Sustainability: Higher Education´s New Fundamentalism. Colorado: Polaris Books.

Ponzini D. (2018) Design and Building Review. The Fall of The Starchitect: Is the Age of the Celebrity Architect Finally Ending? Interview by Kingsland. Design & Build Review. Retrieved from: https://designbuild.nridigital. com/design_build_review_issue_42_february_2018/the_fall_of_the_starchitect_is_the_age_of_the_celebrity_architect_finally_ending.

Quacquarelli Symonds. (2017). Top Architecture Schools in 2017. Retrieved from https://www.topuniversities.com/university-rankings- articles/university-subject-rankings/top-architecture-schools-2017.

Rawes P. (2013). Relational Architectural Ecologies. Architecture, Nature and Subjectivity. London: Routledge.

Reinhart C., Jones N. (2017). Modeling Urban Energy Flows for Sustainable Cities and Neighborhoods. MIT Architecture. Retrieved from: https://architecture.mit.edu/subject/spring-2017-4432.

Rigolon A., Németh J. (2020). Green gentrification or ‘just green enough’: Do park location, size and function affect whether a place gentrifies or not? Urban Studies, 57(2), 402–420.

Schroeder T. (2018). Giving Meaning to the Concept of Sustainability in Architectural Design Practices: Setting Out the Analytical Framework of Translation. Sustainability, 10(6), 1710.

Scofield J. H. (2009). Do LEED-certified buildings save energy? Not really. Energy & Buildings, 41, 1386-1390.

Shari Z., Mohd F. Z. J. (2006) Towards a more Sustainable Architectural Education in Malaysia. International Journal on Sustainable Tropical Design Research & Practice, 1(1), 57-64.

Soper K., Thomas L., Ryle M. (Eds.). (2009) The Politics and Pleasures of Consuming Differently; Palgrave: London, UK, 2009.University of Cambridge (2017). Department of Architecture. Undergraduate. Retrieved from: https://www.arct.cam.ac.uk/admissions/undergraduate/the-course/year-1.

Spirn A. (2016). Ecological Urbanism Seminar. MIT Course Catalog. Retrieved from: http://catalog.mit.edu/subjects/4/.

UCL Bartlett. (2017). MSc Environment and Sustainable Development. Retrieved from: https://www.ucl.ac.uk/bartlett/development/programmes/postgraduate/msc-environment-and-sustainable-development.

UCL Bartlett. (2017). Architecture BSc Program. Retrieved from: https://www.ucl.ac.uk/bartlett/architecture/programmes/undergraduate/bsc-architecture.

UCL Bartlett. (2019). Architecture BSc (ARB/RIBA Part 1). https://www.ucl.ac.uk/bartlett/architecture/programmes/undergraduate/bsc- architecture/programme-overview.

University of Cambridge. (2017). Department of Architecture. Retrieved from: https://www.arct.cam.ac.uk/admissions/undergraduate/the- course/year-1.

University of Hong Kong. (2016). Faculty of Architecture. Retrieved 2017, from Syllabi for the Degree of Bachelor of Art in Architectural Studies: http://www.arch.hku.hk/media/upload/2016-17-BAAS-4-year-Syllabi.pdf.

Ursprung P. (2017). ETH homepage. Course Catalog. Retrieved 06 2017, from History of Art and Architecture: http://www.vvz.ethz.ch/Vorlesungsverzeichnis/lerneinheitPre.do?semkez=2017W&ansicht=ALLE&lerneinheitId=118063〈=de

Wals A. E. J., Jickling B. (2002). Sustainability in higher education: From doublethink and newspeak to critical thinking and meaningful learning. International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education, 3, 221-232.

Wargo J. (2010). LEED Building Standards Fail to Protect Human Health. Yale Environment 360. Retrieved from: https://e360.yale.edu/features/leed_building_standards_fail_to_protect_human_health.

Williams A. (2008). The Enemies of Progress: The Dangers of Sustainability (Vol. 60). Exeter.

Williams A. (2013). Five views on sustainability in architectural education. The Architects´ Journal. Retrieved from: https://www.architectsjournal.co.uk/home/students/five-views-on-sustainability-in-architectural-education/8651398.article.

Williamson T., Radford A., Bennetts H. (2003). Understanding Sustainable Architecture. New York: Spon Press.

Wright J. (2003). Introducing sustainability into the architecture curriculum in the United States. International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education, 4(2), 100-105.

Zumthor P. (2006). Atmospheres: architectural environments, surrounding objects. Berlin: Birkhäuser.

Copyright (c) 2020 International Journal of Environmental Science & Sustainable Development Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
ie